For J.Crew in Canvas, hibiscus print and shibori tie-dye
For Madewell in black perfed leather.
I have a shoe problem and love them all. Need your votes!
UPDATE - note on sizing: I did follow the sizing recommendation on the JCrew website (i.e. purchased a 4H in Vans to get my usual women's 6). I tried to tell the Madewell SA the same thing, since I was ordering over the phone, and she just did the calculation herself using my usual women's size. So if you're going to Madewell, they might have it already converted for you to women's US sizes. Go with your true size.